Was tolkien gay

J.R.R. “The thing is that Stephen Beresford, one of our writers, is gay, and he read all of the letters and all of the poems, and he was like, % fact that Geoffrey was gay,” Karukoski told me. Although it is not yet clear how much LGBTQ+ representation the new series will have, if any, early reviews indicate elf Elrond, played by Robert Aramayo, may be gay.

Etc, etc. And in Frodos condition, espacially later, I think being gay or straight isn't something he worries about. Yes, "heterosexuality" didn't exist either. Feeling good John Ronald Reuel Tolkien, CBE, (3 January, – 2 September, ) was a philologist and writer, best known as the author of The Hobbit and its sequel The Lord of the .

Tolkien based Frodo and Sam’s relationship on ones he had seen and experienced in World War I — that between a usually upper-class officer and his batman, a usually lower-class man who served. So if Tolkien wants to stop me from writing my dumb gay hot takes he'll have to crawl out of his grave and fight me over it!!

Share the love Tolkien met another orphan, Edith Mary Bratt, when he was 16, and in the summer of they fell in love. And he was Just Some Guy. Some random sad guy with a lot of Baggage who wrote a lot of things. Your face belongs on my pillow Unpopular Opinions meme!

I don't feel like Sam is gay for example because of the way he is speaking about Rosi at Mount Doom and even marries her and has kids with her later. Just finished a great workout! Morgan prohibited them from meeting until Tolkien was 21; when Tolkien reached that age in he proposed to her, and they became engaged.

Sign up Log in. Tolkien is an internationally renowned fantasy writer. And I deeply empathize with the desire to prove that the gay subtext in the original books was intentional. I don't feel like Sam is gay for example because of the way he is speaking about Rosi at Mount Doom and even marries her and has kids with her later.

I feel more like Merry and Pippin are gay 🤔. He was the author of the high fantasy works The Hobbit and The Lord of .

is frodo gay

Although it is not yet clear how much LGBTQ+ representation the new series will have, if any, early reviews indicate elf Elrond, played by Robert Aramayo, may be gay. Like: there's a bit in the commentary of the PJ films where gay actor Ian McKellan talks about how he deliberately tried to ensure the homoerotic elements of the book were preserved, like the scene in Rivendell where Frodo wakes up and Sam immediately rushes over to take his hand.

Idk, I feel like a lot of LOTR fans including me have gotten anons complaining at them about how "reading gay subtext into Tolkien is against the author's intent" or whatever excuse they're using to be homophobic now. But if he did crawl out of his grave and fight me I'd let him win because he is a Sad Man and I'd feel sorry for him.

Yes, "heterosexuality" didn't exist either. And in Frodos condition, espacially later, I think being gay or straight isn't something he worries about. But eyyy. J.R.R. John Ronald Reuel Tolkien (/ ˈruːlˈtɒlkiːn /, a 3 January – 2 September ) was an English writer and philologist.

And it's so tempting to respond to those anons by arguing "no, it isn't against Tolkien's intent! And when I first heard that bit of the commentary, it gay the scene forever for me? I feel more like Merry and Pippin are gay 🤔. Tolkien’s life was split between these two: the then very rural hamlet of Sarehole, with its mill, just south of Birmingham; and darkly urban Birmingham itself, where he was.

Anonymous asked:. Tolkien DID intend it! So I really understand wanting to prove that Tolkien intended for the story to be gay-- that he wasn't just a conservative catholic who stumbled into gayness by accident, that he wrote it intentionally. Morgan prohibited them from meeting until Tolkien was 21; when Tolkien reached that age in he proposed to her, and they became engaged.

There was something really special about knowing that the gay subtext in that scene wasn't just there, it was Intentional tm. But honestly like My Hot Take is that the only one who benefits from obsessing over the Inherent Value of Tolkien's intent are whatever corporation currently own the rights Tolkien's intent, lol XD.

If Amazon is the only one who is legally allowed to profit off of Tolkien's Tolkien, then it's in Amazon's best interest to insist that Tolkien's Vision is the only correct way to interpret his work. Tolkien based Frodo and Sam’s relationship on ones he had seen and experienced in World War I — that between a usually upper-class officer and his batman, a usually lower-class man who served.

Anyone was love people-watching Tolkien met another orphan, Edith Mary Bratt, when he was 16, and in the summer of they fell in love. That he was creating this world with you in mind, that he WANTED you to be there, that he wanted you to see your own experiences in his story and feel like you belonged in Middle Earth.

He is best known for authoring 'The Hobbit' and 'The Lord of the Rings' trilogy. Tolkien (born January 3,Bloemfontein, South Africa—died September 2,Bournemouth, Hampshire, England) was an English writer and scholar .